Order now from our 100+ sinful sweets

To better serve our customers and guarantee order pickup for Saturday, Sunday or Monday, please place online orders by 5:00 PM FRIDAY.

Please be aware of the following store hours and ordering deadlines for Thanksgiving:


11/22 7 am-4 pm, 11/23 Closed, 11/24 9 am-4 pm

Market Square

11/22 7 am-4 pm, 11/23 Closed, 11/24 9 am-4 pm

Order deadline for in-store pickup: Monday, 11/20 4pm

Thanksgiving Menu 2017 Front Page

Thanksgiving 2017 Menu Page 2



Online orders for Burnt Almond Tortes require a 48 hour notice.
Due to overwhelming demand, we cannot guarantee availability of Burnt Almond Tortes without an online order.

August 2017 cake update png

The Greatest Cake in America

“No cake made in any of the five boroughs of New York holds a candle to Prantl’s amazing burnt almond torte. It is possibly the BEST cake America has to offer.”

-The Huffington Post